When it comes to cookies, Santa (Code Name: Red One) is the undisputed expert—especially those baked by Mrs. Claus. We got our hands on her recipes and stuffed four of Santa’s all-time favorites into a frosting-inspired ice cream for an over-the-top indulgence, straight from the North Pole. Every bite is packed with chocolate crinkle cookies, cinnamon snickerdoodles, spiced gingerbread, and buttery sugar cookies (topped with red and green sprinkles, naturally). A ribbon of rich eggnog custard adds a very merry finishing touch. Skip the milk—grab a pint of this instead.